| Capability |
CopperEgg |
Nagios |
| User Interface |
Unified dashboard, real-time graphs, charts, reports |
“Ugly” GUI, difficult to use |
| Security |
Push-based stats avoid firewall issues |
Poll-based monitoring requires firewall changes |
| Real-Time |
5-second details finds hidden problems fast |
1-minute averages miss performance spikes |
| Hardware Costs |
SaaS-based, no hardware costs |
Pay for hardware, electricity, maintenance |
| Redundancy |
Multiple high availability datacenters, externally hosted |
Pay for redundancy, internal view – when you are down, your monitoring is down |
| Outside-in View |
Monitor from outside-in (website) and inside-out (server) |
No customer experience or outside view |
| iPhone, iPad, Android push, SMS |
Built-in |
Add-on |
| Historical Data |
1 yr data retention including process data |
Add-on |
| Network Resilience |
Alerts when you lose power or network |
Prone to network or power outages |
| Maintenance Costs |
None |
People & system costs ongoing |
| Operations Costs |
None |
People & system costs ongoing |
| Ease of Install |
10-second install |
Not 10-seconds, perhaps days or weeks |
| Tagging |
Alerts, dashboards, user views |
Do it yourself |
| Analytics |
Health, uptime, and aggregate metrics |
Do it yourself |
| Correlation |
Correlate across server, system, and web app performance |
Do it yourself |
| API, Webhooks, Integrations |
Out-of-the-box API, integrations with GitHub, Puppet, Chef, PagerDuty, HipChat, Campfire, or add your own |
Assembly required |
| Annotations |
Auto-annotations on graphs, annotation API |
None |
| Custom Dashboards |
Choose what to display for all metrics, servers and websites |
None |
| Custom Metrics |
Monitor, analyze, view, and alert any metric, any app |
None |